FILL ‘ER UP:
Borderlands: H.L. Mencken’s Struggle With Faith (Kevin Belmonte, September 6th, 2026, Imaginative Conservative)
Part of the answer lies with one essay in the collection. Mencken called this piece “Holy Writ,” and that caught my eye too. Written in 1923, it’s a reflection on the King James Bible. I’d heard Mencken could be unsparing when he wrote about matters of religion. Would he be so here?
There were one or two caustic flashes, but then, this essay seemed strangely subdued. It had lines that were different from anything I’d read by Mencken before. Many of the things he said struck a chord; indeed, they were welcome. Here’s one of them, in which he describes the adamantine beauty and power of the KJV:
To this day it has enchanted the English-speaking peoples so effectively that, in the main, they remain Christians, at least sentimentally. Paine has assaulted them, Darwin and Huxley have assaulted them, and a multitude of other merchants of facts have assaulted them, but they still remember the twenty-third Psalm when the doctor begins to shake his head, they are still moved beyond compare (though not, alas, to acts!) by the Sermon on the Mount, and they still turn once a year from their sordid and degrading labors to immerse themselves unashamed in the story of the manger.
It is not much, but it is something.
Just a few sentences later, Mencken says something that was, as Alistair Cooke had written, “beautifully lucid.” He begins with qualified admiration for the Catholic Church, but closed with words of unqualified praise. “The Latin Church,” he says, “has always kept clearly before it the fact that religion is not a syllogism, but a poem.”
I thought about that for a long time. I think about it still.
Which led to these thoughts.
Maybe Mencken’s caustic prose, along with his stirring passages, flowed from a longing for truth and beauty and ultimate answers. Maybe sometimes we rage against things that aren’t what they ought to be, things that are broken and ugly. Maybe Mencken’s fulminations pointed to “the God-shaped hole in our heart,” as someone once said, or is supposed to have said. Maybe an uneasy believer like him, or someone who wants to believe, can teach us something. I believe that’s true.
